Guest Blog: In Defence of Teaching Assistants

Today's guest blogger is Lisa Ors, one of Classroom's highly valued Teaching Assistants. Lisa has decided to write in defence of Classroom assistants having read an article in The Independent which describes a major study released which suggests that "children are worse off with classroom assistants".

The Independent newspaper recently reported that studies had found “children do worse in test and exams the more time they spend with classroom assistants”. This rather damning statement came as a surprise to me as during my five years working as a teaching assistant my experience contradicts this statement.

In many schools, teaching assistants are not only a bonus but essential. Within the majority of special schools, classes would be unable to take place with the teacher alone, where individual or small group support is necessary and where personal care is required. During my time I have worked in both special and mainstream schools with all age groups. Roles have included one to one support, learning mentor, small inclusion groups and general teaching assistant work. Times where it has been easier to monitor direct impact have been both when I have worked with with pupils that require one to one support as well as facilitating SATs (Standard Assessment Tests) preparation groups. There has been clear evidence through exam results, academic and personal progress that the support of a TA is conducive to supporting a pupils learning and social development.

The report does however explore some reasons why the initial claim may be the case. One reason given was the fact that many teachers are not trained to manage teaching assistants. Indeed I have found that where the teacher does not give clear instruction, information and targets to their TA, it minimises the impact that the role can have. Or, where the teacher expects their support staff to take on some of the teacher’s responsibilities, this (clearly) too does not maximise the potential of all classroom staff and therefore the pupils. Where good management is in place the role of the TA can be very successful in supporting the pupils in their learning thus creating a more rewarding experience for all involved.

The valuable role that TA's play in supporting schools should not be undermined, and with good management and team work they can only be seen as a beneficial contribution to the schools in which they work.

So what do you think? Lisa clearly raises some important points. As ever, your comments are always welcomed.